Voya Financial has delivered strong multi year gains for shareholders, which puts a spotlight on whether the current share price lines up with the returns it earns on its capital. With the stock recently at US$96.56 and governance concerns in the headlines, the core issue is how well that price matches the value suggested by the business returns behind it.
- Over the past 5 years, Voya Financial has returned 55.6%, which raises the question of whether those share gains reflect the returns the business is actually generating on its capital base.
- TOMS Capital Investment Management pressing for a no confidence vote in the board and management highlights questions about capital allocation and stewardship, which can influence how effectively future profits are reinvested or returned to shareholders.
- Prefer to judge Voya Financial on earnings? See why Voya Financial's 15.4x P/E tells a different valuation story.
For investors, the debate is whether the current price is adequately supported by the level and quality of returns Voya Financial earns on the capital it deploys.
If you are weighing Voya Financial against other opportunities that focus on capital efficiency, it can help to compare it with companies in our 26 high quality undervalued stocks
Is Voya Financial a Bargain on Excess Returns?
The Excess Returns model evaluates how much profit Voya Financial can earn above its equity cost over time. On this view, the business is priced on a $96.56 share price, while analysts expect a stable earnings power of $8.14 per share on a book value base of $51.72 per share. That pairs with an average Return on Equity of 15.39%, which the model treats as comfortably ahead of a $4.33 per share equity cost.
The gap between that earnings power and the equity charge feeds into an excess return of $3.82 per share, with stable book value projections nudging up to $52.91 per share based on estimates from 4 analysts. Despite TOMS Capital Investment Management pushing a no confidence vote on governance and capital allocation, the Excess Returns framework still places Voya Financial's estimated intrinsic value substantially above where the stock currently trades. Find out what Voya Financial could be worth using our Excess Returns estimate.
The Voya Financial Narrative: What Would Justify Today's Price?
Narratives for Voya Financial pick up from this valuation puzzle and spell out which specific paths for future growth, profitability, and earnings would need to play out for the stock to be worth materially more or materially less than today’s price, based on scenarios shared on Simply Wall St’s Community page. Where a single ratio or model gives one output, these narratives break down the future that output relies on so you can track how reality compares over time.
Community views on Voya Financial are split between those who see workplace scale and cash generation as underappreciated and those who focus on execution risk and earnings volatility.
Bull case: 11% undervalued
"The expanding workplace-centric ecosystem, with about 1.3b of combined assets across Retirement and Investment Management and access to more than 50,000 employers and 18 million customers, gives Voya Financial more scope to move retirement participants into wealth and investment products…"
Discover why this Narrative puts Voya Financial at 11% undervalued.
Bear case: 7% overvalued
"Reliance on elevated Stop Loss pricing, including approximately 24% rate increases on the 2026 book, could be difficult to sustain if medical trend moderates…"
Explore why this Narrative puts Voya Financial at 7% overvalued.
One more angle on Voya Financial worth checking before you move on
Valuation only tells part of the story for Voya Financial, since recent research checks have flagged specific areas of concern that investors may want to weigh carefully before committing fresh capital. Take a closer look at 1 warning sign before settling on a valuation.
Have feedback on this article? Concerned about the content? Get in touch with us directly. Alternatively, email editorial-team@simplywallst.com