-+ 0.00%
-+ 0.00%
-+ 0.00%
At a time when Kioxia's stock price was deeply adjusted, the risk-return ratio was already attractive after downside risks in the industry were reduced by excessive pricing and valuation
Share
Listen to the news

The Zhitong Finance App learned that in a newly released research report, Morgan Stanley pointed out that Japan's NAND flash memory manufacturer Kioxia's performance guidelines for the third quarter of the 2027 fiscal year ending December raised market concerns that the price of its products might enter a downward trend, compounded concerns that artificial intelligence (AI) data center construction might slow down after the US midterm elections, driving the company's stock price lower. However, the bank believes that Kioxia's current stock price seems to have taken into account a far more serious decline in the industry than it predicted, thus forming an attractive risk-reward ratio. The bank maintains an “gain” rating on Kioxia. The target price is 24,000 yen, which has room for 164% increase from the stock's closing price of 9091 yen on November 13.

According to reports, Kioxia's previously announced results for the second quarter of fiscal year 2027 showed that revenue for the quarter increased 40.3% month-on-month to 2.4800 trillion yen; IFRS operating profit increased 57.1% month-on-month to 1.9947 trillion yen, higher than the market's general expectation of 1.95 trillion yen; net profit to mother increased 61.0% month-on-month to 1.3557 trillion yen, slightly lower than the 1.37 trillion yen generally anticipated by the market. According to the company, revenue growth during the quarter was mainly due to a sharp rise in the average selling price (ASP) of products driven by demand for generative AI data centers and an increase in bit shipments.

However, Kioxia expects revenue of 2.50 trillion yen, operating profit of 1.9950 trillion yen, and net profit to mother of 1.3600 trillion yen for the third quarter of fiscal year 2027, up only 0.8%, 0.0%, and 0.3%, respectively, from the previous quarter, which is basically the same as in the second quarter, while general market expectations were 2.90 trillion yen, 2.35 trillion yen, and 1.62 trillion yen, respectively — guidance was 14% to 16% lower than expected.

Dama said that Kioxia's performance guidelines for the third quarter meant that its revenue and operating profit remained roughly equal month-on-month, and its performance lagged behind the performance forecasts of its peers. However, over the past three quarters, the company has achieved significant price increases not only in data center applications, but also in smart devices and personal computers (PCs). On a semi-annual basis, the bank expects Kioxia's GB shipment growth and average price increase in the second half of 2026 to surpass that of many of its peers.

Damo added that Kioxia's month-on-month revenue growth rate has already slowed from the 84% peak recorded in the fourth quarter of fiscal year 2026 ending in March, and the year-on-year growth rate is almost certain to decline from the third quarter of fiscal year 2027. Furthermore, as earnings growth slows, the valuation multiples of cyclical stocks tend to shrink. Therefore, the trend of Kioxia's stock price falling and valuation multiples shrinking since June can be seen as being in line with this historical scale.

But things are different this time around. Damo believes that growing demand for AI storage and limited supply should keep the storage market tight during the 2027-2028 calendar year, even if the increase in product prices slows down. However, in the previous industry cycle, AI was not a demand-driven factor.

Damo pointed out that under a multi-year long-term supply agreement (LTA) and a one-year contract, Kioxia's 2027 production capacity has been fully allocated and is “sold out.” For 2028, multi-year long-term supply agreements have covered far more than 50% of shipments in GB capacity.

Kioxia deepens business partnerships with enterprise customers and hyperscaler customers through long-term supply agreements, and has also signed such agreements with technology leaders in other key vertical sectors. Although the terms of the agreement vary, even under multi-year agreements, prices are usually negotiated quarterly, and there is a price floor. Agreements do not always require an advance payment from the customer; on the contrary, such agreements often have no price cap.

As to why Kioxia did not announce a stock repurchase plan on October 30, Dama believes that according to Japan's “Company Law”, the amount of money Kioxia can currently use to distribute according to law is insufficient to support large-scale stock repurchases. The company anticipates that the relevant procedures required to increase this amount will be completed by the end of December. Therefore, the bank believes that the company is likely to consider implementing large-scale stock repurchases in the March 2027 quarter.

Regarding the prospects for AI data center construction after the US midterm elections, Damo predicts that changes in approval and regulatory policies in Texas and Ohio will delay about 20% of the construction projects planned in the US in the 2028 calendar year until 2029. This part of the project involves 5 gigawatts of power capacity and is a construction delay rather than a cancellation of the project.

Damo finally pointed out that the catalytic factors that Kioxia's stock price may face include: progress in valuations related to raising the amount that can be distributed according to law, thereby raising market expectations for shareholder returns; progress in strategic enterprise-grade solid-state drive (SSD) products; and at a time when market uncertainty intensifies and investors seek new investment narratives, the development progress of Kioxia GP series products will be particularly positive — this series of products is aimed at extending and supplementing the functions of high-bandwidth memory (HBM).

Disclaimer:Webull uses external vendor Google Translation Service for news translations where we endeavour to ensure these are correct, however, we recommend that you please double-check this information accordingly. Webull is not responsible for translation errors or issues.
What's Trending