
The Zhitong Finance App learned that seven years ago, an existential crisis forced Deutsche Bank (DB.US) to divest part of its global investment banking business. Today, its fixed income division is expected to generate record revenue: this year's revenue is expected to be close to €10 billion (US$11.2 billion), almost double that of 2019.
The revival is due at least in part to investment banking veteran Ram Nayak, who has survived multiple layoffs at Deutsche Bank over the past few years. Under the leadership of this London-based fixed income trading executive, the business has regained market share since its trough and is now among the top fixed income institutions in Europe and Asia.
Encouraged by this success, Deutsche Bank has set its sights on rebuilding the US trading business, targeting sectors such as energy, emerging market credit, and mortgages — a business that once pushed the bank to the edge of a cliff ten years ago, when regulators were prosecuting global banks for selling securities fueling the financial crisis.
“Growing in the US is our priority,” said Nayak, 62. “We think it's very feasible to get into the top five in the US market.”
Global share rebounded, and fixed income was second only to Bank of America
Globally, Deutsche Bank is already one of the top debt trading institutions. Citing data from Crisil Coalition Greenwich, Nayak said that its fixed income and foreign exchange market share had risen from a low of 8.4% in 2020 to 11.1% in the first half of this year. According to estimates, if Deutsche Bank's fixed income revenue this year reaches 11.2 billion US dollars, it will rank second only to Bank of America (BAC.US) and ahead of Morgan Stanley (MS.US).
However, the US market has always been difficult for European institutions to overcome, and the latter are generally smaller in size. Also, unlike Deutsche Bank, which withdrew from the stock business during a restructuring, its US rival has a huge stock division that can balance any weakness in the debt market.
Last quarter, Deutsche Bank had to watch as many of its peers reaped huge profits from stock trading, with BNP Paribas reporting a 50% surge. Previously, Deutsche Bank abandoned its stock business during the restructuring process, and BNP Paribas immediately took over Deutsche Bank's brokerage business division.
Dependence on fixed income — the business accounts for 84% of investment bank revenue in the first nine months of this year — means there is little room for fault tolerance as Nayak seeks to rebuild its US business.
Nayak: “revenue generator+risk manager” emerging from the crisis
Having worked for Citigroup (C.US), Merrill Lynch, and Credit Suisse, and joined Deutsche Bank in 2009, Nayak is one of the few executives who survived multiple management shuffles after CEO Christian Sewing (Christian Sewing) took over. Zewin appointed him as Head of Fixed Income and Foreign Exchange Sales and Trading in 2019, and a few years later he was appointed Co-Head of the Investment Bank.
“Ram Nayak is one of the best appointments I've made,” Zewin said, adding that he “reshaped and rebuilt” the department. “What makes him unique is that he combines the mindset of a revenue generator with that of a risk manager.”
When Nayak took over, the investment banking business was in decline. Tighter regulations and costly lawsuits from past misconduct, most of which involved the fixed income sector, have led to a crisis of trust, and its financial strength has been questioned as a result.
Deutsche Bank adopted gradual reduction measures: it withdrew from most of its commodity business in 2013 and reduced its business segments. In 2015, it stopped acting as an agent for transactions in products such as residential mortgage-backed securities. However, the decline in revenue, combined with high fines, sent the company into a spiral of decline.
The following year, Deutsche Bank reached a $7.2 billion settlement with the US Department of Justice over allegations that it misled residential mortgage-backed securities investors prior to the financial crisis. The US initially requested $14 billion. This figure frightened the market and caused some customers to reduce their business dealings with the German bank.
After Zewen became CEO in 2018, he decided that the bank did not have enough capital to invest in fields that were not large enough on its own. He quit stock trading and reduced the capital allocated to the interest rate business. This round of restructuring actually ended Deutsche Bank's attempt as an all-rounder global investment bank, leaving behind a small business system centered on fixed income and foreign exchange transactions and transaction consulting.
Nayak realized he needed to focus on a few core areas where Deutsche Bank could compete with Wall Street banks — government and corporate bonds and foreign exchange and emerging markets — and rebuild from the bottom up. This means that priority should be given to developing it as a basic business for customers to trade small securities, also known as traffic trading.
“In 2019, I realized we were focusing too much on the area of structures and solutions, and we needed to rebuild the traffic business,” Nayak said. “Rebuilding a large traffic engine is probably the single most important decision I've made.”
Trading Engine Reconstruction: Technology, Interest Rates, and Credit Go Hand in Hand
What supports the restructuring of the traffic business is a set of internal trading platforms called Kannon. The platform was developed under the leadership of Sam Wisnia (Sam Wisnia), who joined in late 2014, to improve pricing, analysis, risk measurement, and profit and loss accounting in interest rate and credit transactions. Nayak commented that this system allows the company to “expand the scale of transactions very significantly.” Visnia has since left Deutsche Bank.
The external environment also helped: central banks around the world began to reduce quantitative easing, and previously depressed government bond yields and curbed volatility picked up. The rebound in demand, the ability to expand at low cost brought about by technology platforms, and successive credit rating increases together form the key pillars of Deutsche Bank's transformation.
“Deutsche Bank has maintained a particularly firm commitment at a time when the willingness of some competitors to invest in fixed income and foreign exchange businesses has declined,” said Andreas Thomae (Andreas Thomae), manager of Dekabank funds.
The Kannon platform helped Nayak expand its interest rate business, that is, trading securities whose prices are mainly affected by macroeconomic factors, such as government bonds. The business increased annual revenue by more than €1 billion compared to its 2019 low.
In 2022, Liz Truss's mini budget caused British Treasury yields to soar and the pound to fall, and Deutsche Bank earned more than 100 million euros on the British pound inflation desk alone. According to people familiar with the matter, as the central bank tightened its policy, the short-term interest rate trading desk (including foreign exchange swaps and interest rates) achieved revenue of more than 500 million euros under the leadership of former head Josh Hooker (Josh Hooker); the European government bond business contributed more than 200 million euros.
Credit transactions have also rebounded. According to people familiar with the matter, the US struggling product team's profits more than doubled in the first quarter of this year, partly due to shortening a basket of software companies' debts. According to reports, the securities transactions affected by EchoStar Corp.'s imminent bankruptcy last year made a net profit of more than 100 million US dollars for Deutsche Bank.
Although most of the gains in credit and interest rates come from flow transactions, Deutsche Bank has also made some oversized bets, which are riskier but more rewarding. In 2021, it was expected to profit nearly $1 billion from transactions involving Zim Integrated Shipping Services Ltd. — an Israeli shipping company once in trouble.
In the interest rate business, Aska is pushing traders to carry out internal so-called “elephant hunting” operations, that is, chasing large transactions with countries and companies. One example is an “interest rate locked” swap transaction, which allows a client to issue future debt at a lower current interest rate. According to people familiar with the matter, this can bring Deutsche Bank tens of millions of euros a year in revenue for a single country.
“The risk profile of Deutsche Bank's fixed income business is quite different today,” said Roland Pfaender (Roland Pfaender), an analyst at Oddo BHF. “The risk is clearly not zero, but compared to ten years ago, this business looks very different.”
US expansion focuses on four major areas
While seeking to improve the ranking of the US trading business, Nayak said he is focusing on four different areas. In addition to proxy mortgages and non-agency home loans, there are also emerging market traffic credit and energy — Deutsche Bank is building this business as its corporate clients seek ways to hedge against price fluctuations.
People familiar with the matter said the bank recently hired former Goldman Sachs traders Madhav Janakiraman (Madhav Janakiraman) and Benoit Bosc (Benoit Bosc), as well as at least two senior Morgan Stanley (MS.US) commodity sales executives to strengthen the business. The initiative was led by Kow Atta-Mensah (Kow Atta-Mensah), a former head of commodities at Morgan Stanley, who joined earlier this year and previously headed one of Wall Street's largest commodities traders.
Expansion in energy and other sectors is costly. The cost of recruiting and retaining talent is expected to push investment banks' compensation expenses to nearly 3 billion euros this year, an increase of 39% over 2019. The division's revenue grew by more than 70%, outpacing cost growth, most of it from the fixed income business.
However, a legacy problem in the fixed income sector may still plague Deutsche Bank: several former employees have filed lawsuits claiming over £600 million, accusing the bank of blaming them for controversial derivatives trading errors relating to Banca Monte dei Paschi di Siena SpA (Banca Monte dei Paschi di Siena SpA). Deutsche Bank has settled a related case this year and said the claims are unfounded.