-+ 0.00%
-+ 0.00%
-+ 0.00%
EXCLUSIVE: 'A Louder Debate' Ahead? Democrats' Midterm Gains Put Private Credit's 401(k) Push Under Scrutiny
Share
Listen to the news

Democrats’ gains in the midterm election could bring greater scrutiny to Wall Street’s push to put private credit into America’s $12 trillion-plus retirement market, although a major regulatory reversal remains unlikely.

Doug Greenberg, president of Pinnacle Wealth Advisory, told Benzinga in an interview that congressional control may have less influence on the industry’s direction than the Trump administration and the Department of Labor.

“The big moves came from the executive branch: the August 2025 executive order and what the Labor Department has done since," Greenberg said.

Democrats could increase oversight through hearings and pressure asset managers on valuations, fees and disclosures. However, legislation imposing significant restrictions would face hurdles.

“A bill with real teeth would need 60 Senate votes and a signature, which is a long shot. I’d expect a louder debate that pushes sponsors to tighten their own guardrails.” Greenberg said.

Wall Street Still Wants Your 401(k)

President Donald Trump’s August 2025 executive order encouraged broader access to alternative investments, including private equity and private credit, in defined-contribution retirement plans.

But the industry’s interest predates the administration’s efforts, Greenberg said.

“The administration got things moving, but the industry was already pushing,” he told Benzinga. “Asset managers want into the 401(k) market because that’s where the money is, and that doesn’t change when the politics do.”

Greenberg expects private credit to enter retirement portfolios gradually through professionally managed target-date funds and managed accounts, rather than becoming a standalone option for every retirement saver.

Liquidity And Valuation Risks

The expansion comes as private credit faces questions about its ability to handle investor withdrawals.

Elliott Lorenz, co-founder and CEO of private credit firm Edge Focus, said that recent redemption pressures exposed a mismatch between investor expectations and the liquidity of underlying assets.

That disconnect can strain available liquidity and force managers to sell assets at unfavorable prices, he told Benzinga.

Greenberg also warned about valuation practices and fees, noting that 401(k) accounts are priced daily while private credit assets may be valued quarterly.

“A 401(k) that’s priced daily but holds assets marked quarterly is a mismatch,” he told Benzinga.

The concerns are reflected in non-traded business development companies, or BDCs, which have faced mounting redemption requests in 2026.

Apollo Debt Solutions BDC received repurchase requests for approximately 14.7% of its shares in the third quarter but honored only 5%. HPS Corporate Lending Fund received requests for approximately 11.5% and also fulfilled 5%, according to regulatory filings.

Alex Stepansky, founder of private markets database Corridome, also highlighted valuation concerns. His analysis of eight large BDCs found that 48.7% of first-lien loans due by 2030 with a payment-in-kind component were marked below 90 cents on the dollar as of June 30, compared with 6.4% of comparable cash-pay loans.

Will Private Credit Become Mainstream?

Political uncertainty could delay adoption among cautious employers and retirement-plan sponsors, Greenberg said, particularly as fiduciary liability remains a concern. Larger asset managers and recordkeepers will likely keep developing products, but smaller employers may wait for others to move first.

Greenberg expects private credit to remain a modest allocation within professionally managed retirement products rather than replace traditional portfolio holdings.

“Any fiduciary should be able to explain it, price it and get out of it,” he told Benzinga. “If you can’t, it shouldn’t be there.”

Lorenz said broader adoption will ultimately depend on disciplined underwriting, consistent performance and effective risk management.

“Regardless of the regulatory direction, continued transparency from private credit firms will be essential,” he said.

Photo: Andrei Askirka/Shutterstock

Disclaimer:This article represents the opinion of the author only. It does not represent the opinion of Webull, nor should it be viewed as an indication that Webull either agrees with or confirms the truthfulness or accuracy of the information. It should not be considered as investment advice from Webull or anyone else, nor should it be used as the basis of any investment decision.
What's Trending