-+ 0.00%
-+ 0.00%
-+ 0.00%
Starship's successful recycling made it difficult to boost the stock price! Damo: The market reassesses SpaceX (SPCX.US) business model and strategic risks and maintains a target price of $300
Share
Listen to the news

The Zhitong Finance App learned that Morgan Stanley analyst Adam Jonas pointed out in the latest research report released on November 16 that although SpaceX (SPCX.US) made a major breakthrough in the 15th Starship Test Flight and successfully completed the historic recycling of the spacecraft, the capital market's reaction to this was lackluster. The bank believes that investors are currently paying more attention to the uncertainty of SpaceX's artificial intelligence infrastructure, business model, and cooperation with Tesla (TSLA.US) rather than the benefits brought by a single breakthrough in space technology.

However, Morgan Stanley is still optimistic about SpaceX's long-term development prospects, maintaining its “plus” rating and target price of $300. Compared to the closing price of $137.36 on November 16, this price target represents about 118% of potential upside.

Starship achieved a historic breakthrough, why was the market reacting lukewarm?

Morgan Stanley pointed out that SpaceX's starship test flight can be called an important milestone in space history, yet investors' attention was unexpectedly low. The bank said that despite many recent notable events in the market, on the day Starship completed major technological breakthroughs, the number of investors actively contacting analysts about SpaceX fell to one of the lowest levels in several weeks.

The bank believes that this does not mean that investors are no longer paying attention to SpaceX, but that the market is re-evaluating its business model and strategic risks.

Specifically, SpaceX is gradually transforming from a traditional space company to an artificial intelligence infrastructure operator. Its business involves new fields such as AI computing power, cloud computing, and data center construction. Although these businesses have great potential for growth, they are also associated with the risk that the business model has not been fully verified and that customer concentration is high.

Meanwhile, potential further cooperation between SpaceX and Tesla has also become the focus of investors' attention. Morgan Stanley pointed out that even though some investors are optimistic about the prospects for deepening cooperation between the two companies, they are still unwilling to further increase SpaceX's investment exposure at this stage due to concerns that equity may be diluted in the future.

The attractiveness of SpaceX's valuation highlights that the 2028 price-earnings ratio may be only 17.5 times

Despite cautious market sentiment, Morgan Stanley believes that SpaceX's current stock price already has strong valuation appeal. As of November 16, SpaceX's stock price was $137.36, which is only about 1.7% higher than the $135 initial public offering price. Meanwhile, since the beginning of July this year, Morgan Stanley has raised SpaceX's 2027 and 2028 earnings per share forecasts by 80% and 60%, respectively.

According to the bank's latest forecast, SpaceX's earnings per share for 2026, 2027, and 2028 are expected to be $0.58, $3.95, and $9.91, respectively.

Morgan Stanley pointed out that according to its 2028 profit forecast, and excluding the impact of relevant tax incentives, SpaceX's current 2028 expected price-earnings ratio is about 17.5 times.

This valuation is based on relatively prudent assumptions about the expansion of AI computing power. The bank expects SpaceX's computing power to be 8.3 gigawatts (GW) by the end of 2027, which is lower than Musk's target of 13 gigawatts; by the end of 2028, the computing power scale is expected to further increase to 14 gigawatts.

Furthermore, the bank expects that SpaceX's revenue per unit of computing power will gradually drop from $34 per watt in the first quarter of 2027 to $21 per watt for the whole of 2028.

If consistent market profit expectations are used as summarized by Visible Alpha, and the impact of relevant tax incentives is also excluded, SpaceX's current projected price-earnings ratio for 2028 is only about 11.2 times, lower than Morgan Stanley's projected price-earnings ratio of 16.2 times that of the S&P 500 index over the same period.

According to Morgan Stanley, this means that the market has yet to fully reflect SpaceX's potential for future profit growth.

The synergy between AI, robots, and Tesla may become the next growth driver

In addition to the space business, Morgan Stanley also emphasized that SpaceX's long-term investment value may come more from the deep integration of artificial intelligence, robotics, and the real economy.

The bank believes that the ultimate goal of Musk and SpaceX is not simply to establish a leading new cloud computing enterprise, not only to develop large-scale language models or chatbots, but to build an intelligent system network driven by AI that can perform tasks in the real world.

SpaceX's advantages in global communication networks, space infrastructure, and artificial intelligence computing power, combined with Tesla's capabilities in autonomous driving, robotics, and large-scale manufacturing, may provide an important foundation for this strategy.

As an example, Morgan Stanley said that if 1 million robots are deployed in Austin, Texas in the future, and each robot has an average computing power of 1 kilowatt, then these interconnected robots will form a distributed computing network with a total scale of 1 gigawatt. If the scale is further expanded to 10 gigawatts, its potential application space will be even wider.

The bank believes that this model of distributing computing power in the real world may drive the further expansion of artificial intelligence from digital applications to the real economy.

At the same time, Morgan Stanley also suggested that the future development direction of AI may gradually shift from replacing human work to creating new employment opportunities. The bank anticipates that as intelligent robots and related infrastructure continue to spread, AI may be more closely linked to household income growth and overall economic prosperity, and may even create millions of new jobs in the long term.

Musk's potential collaboration with former Nvidia CEO Wong In-hoon draws attention

Morgan Stanley also mentioned a possible collaboration between Musk and former Nvidia (NVDA.US) CEO Wong In-hoon.

According to the research report, Musk said on social networking platform X last week that it would be an “honor” to hire Hwang In-hoon to join the team. Morgan Stanley believes that this statement is worthy of investors' attention, and raised the question of how Hwang In-hoon's hypothetical addition to SpaceX might affect the company's stock price. However, the research report did not claim that the two parties had reached any cooperation or employment agreement.

On the manufacturing side, Tesla announced on Monday that it will invest an additional 3 billion euros in the Berlin Gigafactory in Germany to support the expansion of the production scale of Cybercab autonomous vehicles by 2029.

Morgan Stanley pointed out that against the backdrop of traditional car manufacturers announcing layoffs and some companies planning to cut tens of thousands of jobs, Tesla's measures to expand investment in the manufacturing industry are in stark contrast.

Furthermore, in response to Musk's large-scale semiconductor manufacturing concept, Morgan Stanley believes that if the relevant plans actually advance to a very large scale, investors may need to pay attention to the development of new manufacturing technologies such as free electron lasers (FEL), not only extreme ultraviolet lithography (EUV) technology currently widely used.

Starship recycling technology or intensifying industry competition Falcon 9 technology licensing is unlikely

In terms of space business, Morgan Stanley believes that after the successful 15th Starship test flight, other space companies may further speed up research and development of reusable rocket technology. The bank anticipates that other US space companies and overseas competitors may increase investment in reusable launch systems, thereby boosting technological competition in the entire space industry.

However, Morgan Stanley gave a clear negative judgment on whether SpaceX might authorize the launch structure of the Falcon 9 rocket to other companies. The bank believes that SpaceX has no power to provide its own mature core launch technology to competitors, and that other companies still need to independently develop their own rocket systems.

Morgan Stanley emphasized that investors should understand SpaceX's development strategy from a longer-term perspective. Just as the company's early launch of satellites for other companies was not its ultimate goal, but rather accumulating capital and technical experience for a larger space business, the current layout of AI computing power and cloud computing may only be an important step in achieving an intelligent real economy in the future.

According to Morgan Stanley's segmented valuation model, of the target price of 300 US dollars given to SpaceX, the space business contributed 8 US dollars, the communications business contributed 111 US dollars, X and Grok businesses contributed 11 US dollars, and the corporate artificial intelligence business contributed 170 US dollars.

The bank pointed out that factors that will further increase SpaceX's valuation in the future include accelerated progress in the reuse of Starships, the increase in Starlink network capacity, the expansion of corporate AI business, and a decrease in computing power infrastructure construction costs.

However, potential risks also cannot be ignored, including Starship reuse falling short of expectations, slowing Starlink user growth, weak AI commercialization performance, rising capital expenditure, and equity dilution due to increased demand for future financing.

Disclaimer:Webull uses external vendor Google Translation Service for news translations where we endeavour to ensure these are correct, however, we recommend that you please double-check this information accordingly. Webull is not responsible for translation errors or issues.
What's Trending