-+ 0.00%
-+ 0.00%
-+ 0.00%
Which ETFs Give You Phillips 66 Without Taking All Its Risks?
Share
Listen to the news

If you like Phillips 66 for its refining and fuel operations, holding just this one stock means living with its company specific risks alone. Simply Wall St flags two of them. Earnings are expected to fall on average over the next few years, and serious issues such as refinery fires or labor disputes could hit output and raise costs. Owning Phillips 66 inside a fund spreads those company level swings across other holdings, and it spreads out the upside too.

Fresh results now give you more to think about. Phillips 66 reported third quarter earnings of US$5.6b and kept refineries running at very high use. Management also approved the Western Gateway Pipeline project and raised the dividend again, which shapes how cash and future spending may look. CRAK, XLE and IYE are three ETFs that include Phillips 66 and allow investors to hold it as part of a wider energy basket.

Fund Phillips 66 weight Rank in fund by weight 5-year annualised return after fees Fee Assets
VanEck Oil Refiners ETF (CRAK) 7.51% #4 of 32 18.8% 0.61% US$493.64 million
State Street Energy Select Sector SPDR ETF (XLE) 4.59% #5 of 24 21.4% 0.08% US$42.09 billion
iShares U.S. Energy ETF (IYE) 4.11% #6 of 44 19.7% 0.37% US$1.84 billion

Rather choose individual stocks than a fund? Explore 38 high quality undervalued stocks.

VanEck Oil Refiners ETF (CRAK)

Marathon Petroleum and Valero Energy together make up 18.3% of CRAK, so a significant portion of your money tracks large US refiners alongside Phillips 66. Reliance Industries adds another sizable position with a different home base and corporate mix, while smaller stakes spread across other refining and integrated oil businesses round things out. Phillips 66 is the fund's fourth-largest holding at 7.51%, which means each US$1,000 in CRAK allocates roughly US$75 to Phillips 66 and the rest across peers with related but not identical operations.

Earnings for Phillips 66 are forecast to decline by an average of 16.5% per year over the next 3 years, and that is a company-level issue. CRAK still links you heavily to the same refining and marketing industry, yet the mix of other refiners and integrated oil groups means cash flows depend on several corporate plans, cost structures and regional markets instead of only Phillips 66.

Not every stock inside CRAK is priced the same way. Find out how many of CRAK's holdings look undervalued.

State Street Energy Select Sector SPDR ETF (XLE)

XLE gives Phillips 66 a mid-tier spot, with 4.59% of the portfolio and about US$46 of every US$1,000 you put in. The rest leans heavily toward integrated oil and gas groups at 44.6% of assets, with ExxonMobil and Chevron together at 42.4% of the fund. You also pick up sizeable exposure to exploration and production at 20.3%, plus smaller slices across refining and marketing, storage and transportation, and equipment and services. This spreads your energy bet across several parts of the sector but keeps it tightly focused on energy businesses.

Operational and labor problems at Phillips 66 facilities, such as fires or refinery labor disputes, could still hurt its throughput, costs and margins. XLE only softens that kind of disruption to the extent that the other 95% or so of the fund depends on different plants, workforces and balance sheets in energy. This leaves you holding a portfolio built around multiple large producers but still exposed if similar incidents affect several refining and pipeline operations at once.

Uncover whether XLE has kept pace with the market over the past week, year and five years

iShares U.S. Energy ETF (IYE)

IYE closely resembles XLE, with much of its money in large integrated oil and gas groups at 41.6% of assets and another big slice in exploration and production at 21.0%. Phillips 66 takes a smaller role at 4.11% of the portfolio, so around US$41 of each US$1,000 goes into the stock, while most of the result comes from holdings such as ExxonMobil Holdings and Chevron, which together are 39.8% of the ETF. Storage and transportation at 14.3%, refining and marketing at 13.6% and equipment and services at 7.8% round out the mix.

Earnings for Phillips 66 are forecast to decline by an average of 16.5% per year for the next 3 years, and that is specific to this business. IYE can soften that single company impact because other holdings depend more on integrated operations and exploration output in different parts of the energy chain, yet investors in the fund still rely heavily on the wider US energy sector moving in their favour.

See what you'd actually own if you bought IYE, from its 44 positions to how much sits in the top 10.

Choosing how to own Phillips 66

In all three ETFs, Phillips 66 is meaningful but not overwhelming, so your real choice is what you want around that core. CRAK leans hardest into refiners and gives you about US$75 of Phillips 66 for every US$1,000, but it also charges the highest fee at US$61 a year on US$10,000. XLE and IYE tilt more toward integrated groups and explorers, and XLE does that at the lowest cost, just US$8 a year on US$10,000.

Recent strong quarterly results show what solid refining conditions can look like for Phillips 66. Earnings are also forecast to decline in coming years. Your call is whether you want a focused refining mix with CRAK, a broader sector fund in XLE, or the widest spread of holdings with IYE.

ExxonMobil Holdings is the largest holding in both XLE and IYE, so you'd own it either way. Check whether ExxonMobil Holdings trades above or below its fair value.

Fund data as of 12 November 2026. Portfolio holdings as of 12 November 2026.

Disclaimer:This article represents the opinion of the author only. It does not represent the opinion of Webull, nor should it be viewed as an indication that Webull either agrees with or confirms the truthfulness or accuracy of the information. It should not be considered as investment advice from Webull or anyone else, nor should it be used as the basis of any investment decision.
What's Trending