
The Zhitong Finance App learned that on the day Morgan Stanley North American retail analyst Simeon Gutman team released the three-quarter report at Home Depot (HD.US), handed over a “change in numbers, no change in opinion” risk-return update: maintaining the “increase” rating and the target price of $400 unchanged, but completely downgrading the EPS forecast for the 2026, 2027, and 2028 fiscal years — to $14.98, 15.85, and 17.25, respectively.
Sales guidelines were raised, EPS guidelines were revised down
The update directly corresponds to Home Depot's three-quarter pre-market report on November 17 and the revised full-year guidance. Damo set the 2026 fiscal year according to the company's caliber: same-store sales increased by about 1.4%, and the adjusted operating profit margin was about 12.8%. Moving forward, the model shows a gradual recovery path with the same store growth rate of +1.4%/+2.6%/+3.5% in the 2026/2027/2028 fiscal year. The operating profit margin contracted first and then expanded — contracted by about 23 basis points in 2026, and rebounded by 11 and 20 basis points respectively in 2027 and 2028.
Notably, the reverse signal: Home Depot's results for the quarter itself exceeded expectations — Q3 sales were $43.4 billion, up 4.9% year over year, higher than market expectations of about 42.8 billion; same-store sales increased 2.2%; adjusted EPS of $3.86. The company also raised the annual total sales growth rate guide to about 4.5%, above the upper limit of the previous 2.5% to 4.5% range. However, the guidelines also showed that the adjusted EPS growth rate for the whole year was only about 2.0% — lower than Damo's previous profit path. Pressure at the gross margin level is called “product and mergers and acquisitions” (combined influence of SRS distribution business), which is partially offset by moderate leverage of sales and management expenses. In other words, the net effect of good news on the revenue side and bad news on the profit margin side is that EPS fell by about 0.05-0.24 dollars each in three years.
Scenario 3: Betting on “the cycle that will eventually come”
The title of this report is pricing for three scenarios. The benchmark scenario of $400 corresponds to 22.5 times the FY2028 EPS of about $17.25, or about 15.5 times EV/EBITDA — Damo clearly stated that the target multiple is higher than the current valuation, on the grounds that Home Depot is the “preferred cyclical stock” within its coverage.
Bull market scenario of $510 (about 24.5 times): The home improvement market ushered in a healthy rebound, driven by a recovery in existing home sales, the Federal Reserve's interest rate cut, and higher GDP growth. The same store growth rate rose to +2.0%/+5.1%/+5.5%. Operating profit margins expanded by 57 and 85 basis points in 2027 and 2028, respectively, and the EPS path was 15.24/17.22/20.13.
Bear market scenario of $265 (about 17.5 times): The home improvement market did not rebound in the 2026-2028 fiscal year — the recovery of existing home sales failed, mortgage interest rates remained high, and wallet shares continued to be lost from the household category after the pandemic. Under this scenario, EPS traded sideways at $14.77 to $14.89 for three years. Operating profit margins were shrinking year after year, and the EBIT growth rate was close to zero or even negative.
The argument for increasing holdings itself has not changed: strong execution, a differentiated professional customer (Pro) ecosystem, and continued investment in stores, digitalization, and distribution networks; Damo expects share growth to support near-end same-store sales, and “when existing home sales finally recover, Home Depot is the best beneficiary.” In the driver framework presented in the report, the core variables of same-store sales are classified into three categories — rising housing prices, existing home sales, and home ownership, while the expansion of profit margins depends on the company's “responsible expense management.” Its quantitative model ranked Home Depot as the 4/5 best target in the 24-month view (5 being least popular), but the 3-month vision only ranked 2/5 — a combination of poor short-term ranking and long-term optimism, which explains why this update chose to repeat rather than increase it.
What is worth noting is the industry coordinate system: Among US stock peers covered by the same hard line retail market, Low.US (LOW.US) also has an increase in holdings ratings — the home furnishing giants share the same “cycle recovery option” logic within their framework, and Home Depot's differentiating chip lies in the depth of the Pro ecosystem. In terms of position structure, active accounts for 50.6% of institutional holdings. The hedge fund sector has a long/short ratio of 1.8 times, and a net exposure of 10.4% — the level of congestion is not high, and there is still room to increase positions if recovery trading starts.
Market pricing and financial background
The risk-neutral probability given by the options market (as of November 17): Within 12 months, the stock price hit about 26.9% above $400, falling below $265 by about 19.5%, and rushing to $510 by only about 4.8% — options pricing acknowledges that there is room for upward movement, but confidence in the bull market is limited. Under the Refinitiv scale, the consensus target price distribution range is 255-425 US dollars, and the rating distribution is 58% increase, 39% neutral, and 3% holdings reduction — Damo's $400 is close to the upper end of the consensus range.
The financial report itself also harbors a layer of governance variables: Home Depot announced on the same day that CFO Richard McPhail will take over as CEO on November 23 to replace Ted Decker (Ted Decker (Chairman of the Board), who took leave of absence due to illness in August but has now left office, Jordan Broggi will take over as CFO, and Ann-Marie Campbell as president and COO. Management changes and superposition guidelines were raised, indicating that the company chose to actively release certainty during the handover window. The structure of the three-quarter report also confirms Damo's Pro story: the unit price of comparable customers increased by 3.0%, the comparable transaction volume decreased by 0.5%, demand from professional contractors hedged the weakness of DIY consumption; online same-store sales increased by about 13%, maintaining double-digit growth for the sixth consecutive quarter.
The most accurate reading of this report is: Damo did not change its position for a slight reduction in the quarterly report, but instead treated Home Depot as an option slip of “falling interest rates+recovery in existing housing turnover” — the EPS reduction was a premium, and the cyclical recovery was a compensation payment.