
How different can three funds tied to the same oil and gas theme really be, and why does that difference matter when Brent is stuck near US$93? When tanker attacks in the Strait of Hormuz collide with a surge in Gulf exports, the price you see on the Brent screen reflects both disruption risk and extra barrels hitting the water. That price feeds straight into revenue per barrel for producers and toll-like fees for pipelines.
You can approach that story through State Street Energy Select Sector SPDR ETF (XLE), Vanguard Energy ETF (VDE) or First Trust North American Energy Infrastructure Fund (EMLP). Each puts your money next to the same headline but in very different businesses. Understanding what you actually own helps you lean toward upstream cash flows, midstream infrastructure or a mix that softens direct oil and gas exposure.
| Fund | Fee | Assets | 5-year annualised return after fees | Top holding |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| State Street Energy Select Sector SPDR ETF (XLE) | 0.08% | US$42.09 billion | 21.4% | ExxonMobil Holdings 24.04% |
| Vanguard Energy ETF (VDE) | 0.09% | US$14.50 billion | 20.9% | ExxonMobil Holdings 23.22% |
| First Trust North American Energy Infrastructure Fund (EMLP) | 0.95% | US$4.22 billion | 15.8% | Enterprise Products Partners 9.12% |
Who gets paid whatever the oil price does? Explore 22 US oil and gas pipeline operators that own the pipelines and terminals the barrels have to move through.
Holdings: 24 | In oil and gas: 92.1% of the fund
This ETF leans hard into companies whose revenue rises directly with oil prices, with 92.1% in oil and gas. You are mainly tied to integrated giants and producers, with ExxonMobil at 24.04%, Chevron at 18.34% and ConocoPhillips at 7.22%. Brent stuck near US$93 feeds straight into higher revenue per barrel for these businesses, which can support cash flow for drilling plans or shareholder payouts. The fund also holds refiners, transport and equipment stocks through its allocations to refining and marketing, storage and transportation, and equipment and services, so not every holding responds to the same driver in the same way.
Investors are largely relying on how the Energy Select Sector Index captures US energy stocks and how a concentrated group of firms reacts to geopolitics in the Strait of Hormuz. A sustained price shock that dents demand or encourages extra non OPEC barrels onto the market could blunt the benefit for some holdings even while helping others maintain volume. ExxonMobil at 24.04% carries much more weight in that equation than ConocoPhillips at 7.22%, which gives the biggest position far more influence on how this ETF behaves than the smaller one.
Not every stock inside XLE is priced the same way. Find out how many of XLE's holdings look undervalued.
Holdings: 116 | In oil and gas: 88.8% of the fund
This ETF gives you a very similar mix to XLE, with about 83% of the money sitting in the same companies and ExxonMobil at 23.22% alongside Chevron at 14.66%. Brent around US$93 feeds into their upstream barrels in much the same way, while ConocoPhillips at 6.37% adds more pure exploration and production to that core. The difference is breadth. With 116 holdings spread across integrated producers, exploration and production, refining, storage and transportation, and equipment, the single stock impact is diluted even though ExxonMobil and Chevron together still account for 37.9% of the fund.
Investors are watching how that broader list of energy stocks responds if tanker attacks keep risk premia in the oil price while Gulf exports stay high. The index this ETF tracks and the 88.8% tilt to oil and gas leave you dependent on how long Brent holds near current levels and on how refiners, infrastructure groups, and suppliers adjust to any demand changes. The structure provides a close substitute for XLE with more secondary holdings to spread business specific shocks, but there is still concentrated exposure to a handful of global majors.
Compare how far VDE is ahead of or behind the market across six periods
Holdings: 61 | In oil and gas: 38.8% of the fund
Enterprise Products Partners, the largest position at 9.12%, runs energy infrastructure that collects fees for moving and storing hydrocarbons rather than selling barrels outright. Energy Transfer at 7.46% and MPLX at 4.51% add more pipeline and storage exposure around that theme. Brent near US$93 can still matter for these businesses because higher upstream cash flows can support volumes and throughput, while the fund’s 37.1% in oil and gas storage and transportation sits alongside sizeable stakes in electric, gas, and multi-utilities that are less tied to the oil price.
Investors in this ETF are accepting a different balance than XLE or VDE, with Enterprise Products Partners and Energy Transfer together at 16.6% and a fee of 0.95% compared with 0.08% and 0.09% for the earlier funds. Most of the portfolio, including the electric and gas utilities, leans more on regulated or contracted infrastructure earnings than direct swings in Brent. This leaves you depending on how those utility style assets perform if the oil price excitement fades faster than expected.
Ten companies make up 47.1% of EMLP. Find out which ones, and how much each carries.
Think of XLE and VDE as a direct line into the oil and gas story tied to Brent near US$93. Both funds are heavily in the sector, with 92.1% for XLE and 88.8% for VDE, and they share 9 of their 10 biggest positions, which already account for 76% of XLE and 65% of VDE. XLE is more concentrated, with ExxonMobil as a single large anchor, while VDE spreads a similar set of holdings across more companies. On cost, the difference is small on a US$10,000 position, with XLE at about US$8 a year and VDE at about US$9.
EMLP plays a different role. Only 38.8% is in oil and gas, with most of the portfolio in electric, gas and multi-utilities plus storage and transportation. That shifts the focus from producers’ revenue per barrel to infrastructure and utility earnings, although the fee of roughly US$95 a year on US$10,000 is higher. Producers benefit when geopolitical risk keeps prices elevated and production costs do not spike. The decision is whether you want XLE’s tighter producer tilt, VDE’s broader sector mix, or EMLP’s infrastructure and utility balance, and how that lines up with your view, risk tolerance and fee sensitivity.
ExxonMobil Holdings is the largest holding in both XLE and VDE, so you'd own it either way. Check whether ExxonMobil Holdings trades above or below its fair value.
Fund data as of 31 October 2026. Portfolio holdings as of 31 October 2026.
Have feedback on this article? Concerned about the content? Get in touch with us directly. Alternatively, email editorial-team@simplywallst.com