-+ 0.00%
-+ 0.00%
-+ 0.00%
Scaling Into a Losing Position: An NDX 0DTE Short Butterfly Off the Gamma Map
Share
Listen to the news

On Wednesday, November 18, the TradeGuidance gamma map had the Nasdaq-100 (NDX) in positive gamma both before the open and at the 10:05 a.m. ET rerun. A same-day NDX put butterfly opened at 10:05 went against me for the first hour, I added a second fly at 11:05, and both closed at 11:54 for +$3,082.19 net on two lots. This is a case study in what the map showed, why I added, and what that decision really involved.

What the 8:40 map said

Before the open, /NQ at 27,296 implied NDX near 27,222, up from Tuesday's 27,001.78 close. The map read positive gamma, the regime where dealer hedging tends to absorb moves rather than add to them.

NDX level (8:40 a.m. ET) Value What it means
Regime Positive, +$288M per 1% Hedging tends to dampen moves
Call wall 27,490 Overhead resistance
Largest gamma strike 27,150 Pin / magnet
Put wall 27,000 Support to watch
Gamma flip 26,850 Below it, hedging starts to amplify moves
ATM straddle 521 points The market's expected move for the day
Trend-day odds 15% A heuristic, not a forecast

What changed by 10:05

By the 10:05 live run, NDX was at 27,119, about 100 points below what futures had implied before the open. The regime was still positive (about +$341M per 1%), but the map had tightened around price. The call wall had dropped from 27,490 to 27,150, the same strike as the pin, so the overhead cap was now about 30 points away. The put wall stayed at 27,000 and the flip sat at 26,883. The straddle had shrunk to 296 points and the central compression band was 26,530 to 27,200, most of it below where NDX was trading.

Read together, the 10:05 map said NDX was boxed in just under a cap, with more room to drift down toward the put wall and the flip than to break higher.

The trade

The fly used 300-point wings: sell one 27,400 put, buy two 27,100 puts, sell one 26,800 put, for a net credit. Selling the wings and buying the body makes this a short butterfly. It earns most when NDX finishes well away from the 27,100 body, and loses most if NDX settles right on the body. With the body just under the pin and the cap, the trade was a bet that NDX would leave the 27,100 area, most likely to the downside.

  Fly 1 Fly 2 (scale-in)
Filled (ET) 10:05 11:05
Net credit 95.00 ($9,500) 124.00 ($12,400)
Most it could lose 205 points ($20,500) 176 points ($17,600)
Closed (ET) 11:54 11:54
Net debit to close 94.00 ($9,400) 94.00 ($9,400)
Result +1.00 point +30.00 points

The scale-in

NDX did not leave. For the next hour it hovered near the 27,100 body, which is the worst place for a short butterfly: as expiration approaches, a fly centered on price gains value, and a short fly loses money. By 11:05 the same fly was priced at 124, so the first position was down 29 points, about $2,900.

I sold a second fly at that 124 credit. That raised the average credit to 109.50 and gave the trade a better entry, but it also roughly doubled what was at stake. Across both flies, the most the position could lose was $38,100. Adding to a losing position only makes sense if the original reason for the trade still holds. Here the 10:05 map still had the cap right overhead and room below, and nothing had broken.

Then NDX slipped. A good-'til-canceled closing order for both flies at a 94.00 debit, placed at 11:45, filled at 11:54 with NDX near 26,890, just above the gamma flip and roughly 210 points below the body. The first fly about broke even, and the scale-in made nearly all of the profit: 31 points across two lots, $3,100 gross and $3,082.19 after $17.81 in commissions and fees. That is about 8% on the $38,100 at risk.

Three lessons

  1. Recheck the map after the open. Between 8:40 and 10:05, the NDX call wall moved down 340 points to sit on top of price. The premarket map alone would have suggested much more room above.
  2. Know what time does to the structure. A short butterfly with price sitting on the body bleeds as the day goes on. If price isn't moving away, the clock is working against you.
  3. A scale-in is a new decision to add risk. It improved the average entry, but it doubled the maximum loss. Decide in advance whether you will add, at what price, and what would make you stop instead. If the map had flipped or the thesis had broken, the right move would have been to close, not add.

Disclosure

These were trades in a TradeGuidance managed trading account, traded by the Lead Analyst. Results are shown before and after commissions and fees. Gamma levels are model output from public-style assumptions, not a measurement of actual dealer positioning. NDX options are European-style and cash-settled. NDX levels at entry, scale-in and exit are approximate, inferred from the 10:05 live map and the option fills.

All investments involve risk. This material is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice. Options can lose their full value quickly; adding to a losing position increases risk; past results do not predict future results. © Trade Guidance 2026.

This article contains syndicated content. We have not reviewed, approved, or endorsed the content, and may receive compensation for placement of the content on this site. For more information please view the Barchart Disclosure Policy here.
Disclaimer:This article represents the opinion of the author only. It does not represent the opinion of Webull, nor should it be viewed as an indication that Webull either agrees with or confirms the truthfulness or accuracy of the information. It should not be considered as investment advice from Webull or anyone else, nor should it be used as the basis of any investment decision.
What's Trending